Promethea Redux

topic posted Tue, May 15, 2007 - 1:53 AM by  offlineSteamPoof!
So, I finished the second book (and am about to start the third) and I must agree with everyone... this book... is AMAZING. The art, the story, the writing -- everything is just SO impressive!

I post this because I may not have rushed to read it were it not for the recommendations of folks in the post about which book was the best -- I have to agree. Top 10 is no where close to this book in scope or execution.

So, what are your thoughts about Tom Strong?

Thanks everyone.
posted by:
SteamPoof!
Seattle
  • Promethea is probably my favorite in terms of literary accomplishment, profundity, teaching/ making theories of magick concrete-- but Tom Strong is just as much fun of another kind: the Strong books are like finding a long lost, much beloved series of pulp novels or comics from a former age that you never knew existed. Teenagers could read it, but adults enjoy it too. Tom's morality is upward and stalwart as any Victorian hero's but with a modern's tolerance for difference and anti-imperialism. The supporting characters are great, the plots are original twists on comic/science fiction tropes, and it's just a whole lot of fun. It's also goofily self-referential in its humor, just the way a good comic book universe should be.
    • I haven't read the tom strong books but get the feel i would agree with Michael.

      On the other hand I felt Tom was a bit out of place in promethea. Almost like an
      old habit for a guy who has come so far with the graphic novel, comics format that
      he feels it is right / a good idea to keep touching base with the genres superhero past,
      but I felt it was so unneccessary in promethea, although it wasn't really bad either.

      certainly the weakest least important part of the books though,
      cheers
      revv
  • I think Tom Strong and Promethea are two sides of the same coin. Tom Strong epitomizes the best of the Yang principle - active, physical, eminently rational, symbolized by the upward-pointing triangle he wears, half of the six-pointed Star of David that represents, like the yin-yang, the intermingling of the male/female energies. Promethea represents the Yin side -the unconscious, the mystic, magical, intuitive side. They balance each other prefectly in this world, though one could say that Promethea far outstrips Tom Strong because of her connection with all the realms beyond our physical universe.

    Both characters meld with their "opposites" - Tom Stong has a black wife and a "good" biracial daughter, and a "bad" son who represents the whole white supremist view that's everything negative about the Yang side. Promethea is half Anglo, half Latino in her mortal form, and distinctly African/Egypitian in her heroic form, and has a white boyfriend (though he's not given nearly as much character development as Tom Strong's wife Dahlua). More Yin-Yang symbology, in other words.
    • Funny, it never occurred to me to look at it that way - Promethea as Yin, Tom Strong as Yang. Excellent notion.
      • except Tom is a classic superhero...
        no doubt about it...
        (and I do tend to find superheros rather boring)
        there is nothing about Promethea that makes her
        a superhero or a "science hero" execpt that she
        can be put in that category because she can fly and
        has powers.... but if there were no other superheros
        in the book one would not think of her in those terms...
        she is a mythological hero, a god or goddess principle...
        which makes the contrast going the other way to superheros
        somewhat interesting in that they have the same kinds of
        powers but we view them in a much more "science" or
        materialistic kind of way....
        so perhaps a more spiritual / material contrast than yin / yan
        but interesting....I don't think much contrast was actually
        highlighted though in the story other than to put the goddess
        character up as a "science heroine" and then just let the
        comparison lie.
        Thinking of it in these terms is somewhat more interesting but
        it didn't add much to the story.
        I think those who write of Tom being a great contrast to Promethea
        must know him from his own books... because if you only know
        him from Promethea... he is rather boring and irrelevant in that story alone.
        all best,
        revv

Recent topics in "Alan Moore"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
NEW ALAN MOORE revVrob 0 September 15, 2008
Interesting "v" video Francis 0 August 31, 2008
Black Dossier Marty 1 May 21, 2008
Which is better in your opinion? Posey 23 April 28, 2008